The tragedy that is South Sudan and warring elite

By Makau Mutua, TheStandard, Kenya, 31/AUG/2016, SSN;

For years, I thought South Sudan was a victim society. History has a wicked way of dealing some people a cruel hand. Bad topography is one. Another is simply having bad neighbours – predatory and malevolent neighbours. Yet another is the cruelty of being colonised – internally, or eternally.

A greedy and myopic elite can be the final straw. But dynamics internal to a people can also do them in. Taken together, a combination of these factors can lead to damnation. That’s what I believe is South Sudan’s curse.

Everything – including the proverbial kitchen sink – has been thrown at South Sudan. It’s a tragedy that the elite in South Sudan can’t stop digging although it’s already in a deep hole.

One of the arguments made by the colonial empires was that the so-called natives lacked sovereignty of reason. That people who were not white – defined as “the other” – lacked faculties of the mind required for self-governance.

By the way, that’s the genesis of international law – as a legal justification to occupy and take territories occupied by “natives” in the Americas, Africa, Asia, and the Pacific. These lands were terra nullius – no man’s land.

This Eurocentric worldview held that non-whites were subhuman and that it was the duty of the white man – predestination, or white man’s burden – to raise backward peoples to full humanity.

This was one rationale for the colonisation and “salvation” of the native, the heathen, the pagan, the savage, the kaffir. Even the League of Nations and the United Nations ratified the legality of colonisation and put colonial peoples under the “trust” or “mandate” of the colonisers.

The period of the “trust” and the “mandate” was supposed to prepare natives for self-governance. Apart from pitting native and against native, this was one function of Lord Lugard’s Indirect Rule.

It was the same logic for Alliance High School – and other missionary or colonial schools – for native children. The idea was to “beat the savage” out of them and “civilise” them so they could first serve the empire, and later an African-ruled state, if it came to that.

That’s why we need to critique Carey Francis again. But I digress. What does all of this have to do with South Sudan?

I think Afro-pessimists and racists must be smiling in glee at the woes in South Sudan and Somalia. Especially South Sudan. A state of dystopia has descended on the poor people of that godforsaken country. I do not know any rational human being who didn’t celebrate the secession of South Sudan from Sudan.

That forced marriage – born out of rape – was doomed from the day it was conceived. The Arabised North owned Sudan where the black African South and the black and Muslim Darfur region were nothing but vassals for plunder. The trauma of decades – centuries – of dispossession is evident in the people of South Sudan.

My point is that those who believe that Africans are incapable of ruling themselves must be dusting racist colonial manuals over afternoon tea. These are the facts.

After years of brutal, genocidal wars, South Sudan walks away from Sudan. It’s blessed with abundant natural resources and untold gushers of oil. The so-called international community is itching to be part of South Sudan’s success. Investors flock.

Advisers on everything from infrastructure to governance flood the country. Kenyan teachers and other professionals, including builders and bankers, rush in to fill the skills gap. For a moment, the world lives in false bliss.

Then everything falls apart. Fighting breaks out between factions of government. Thousands are killed and many more flee. We are back to square one. President Salva Kiir and Vice President Riek Machar – two antagonistic individuals – ignite the conflict.

Alas, it seems that South Sudan didn’t need Sudan to tear itself apart. The world pleads for sense. Kenya and her sane neighbours – and there are not many – exert pressure on Mr Kiir and Dr Machar to put their own people first.

Nothing gives. Ceasefires are signed. Unity meetings are held. Mr Machar even returns to Juba to take his seat as Vice President. Then he flees again – and is replaced by his former comrades.

From where I sit, I can predict with certainty that Mr Machar or his lieutenants will launch a guerilla war against Juba. There’s no respite. What does the tragedy of South Sudan tell us about post-colonial states, and especially the dysfunctional one in South Sudan?

What does it tell us about predatory post-colonial elites who can’t see beyond the bridge of their noses? How do we answer the racist charge “we told you so?”

Is it the post-colonial state that’s incapable of redemption, or the post-colonial elite that’s the doom of many an African state? Can South Sudan save itself?

I am tortured. END

1 Comment

  1. Comrade Yien Mathew says:

    Machar in comma!!!!
    MY Friend,
    No way uncle Machar has finally been kick out in the transitional gov,t of national unity.Uncle Machar should blame weak G10 compose of Pagan Amoum,Fake Dr.Majak Agot,Oyai Deng,Gier Chuang and other individual followers like Gore who mislead him.He throw us out we who were very committed to the battle this is a great lesson for him.Also my brother James Gadet Dak has been lying in the media over Machar discharge from hospital in Khartoum he is just pushing time as i speak to you today the fact is that Dr.Machar is in critical condition and is in comma that is why you did not hear any press conference from him.Currently iam in Khartoum analyze what inspire US secretary of state Kerry to recognize Gai as first vice president of South Sudan it is bse Machar condition can not any more improve to a level of becoming vice president.So my brother the writer consider my words this is the truth on the ground as the bible say the truth set people free.Rember iam more close to Dr.Machar more than any body.

Leave a Reply to Comrade Yien Mathew Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.